Thanksgiving — Proven Gamer
Opinions

GTA VI Isn’t Even Out Yet — And It Already Owns The Game Awards

Grand Theft Auto VI key art — its 212GB pre-load is squeezing other games off PS5 hard drives

Let me get this out of the way first: I’m a GTA fan. I’ve been counting down to tomorrow like everybody else. Grand Theft Auto VI launches November 19, and I’ll be right there in Vice City with the rest of you.

But being a fan doesn’t mean I’m going to sit here and pretend what happened yesterday was okay.

On November 17, The Game Awards announced its 2026 nominees, and Grand Theft Auto VI — a game that is NOT OUT YET — leads the entire show with eight nominations. Eight. Game of the Year. Best Game Direction. Best Narrative. Best Art Direction. Best Score and Music. Best Audio Design. Best Performance. Best Action/Adventure.

Lucia Caminos from Grand Theft Auto VI sitting on a gym bench wearing headphones

Nobody has played this game. Not you. Not me. Not one regular person has pressed start on GTA VI, and it’s already the most nominated game at the biggest awards show in the industry.

How does a game get a Best Narrative nomination for a story nobody has finished? How does it get Best Score and Music when the public hasn’t heard a single track in context? Best Performance — Manni L. Perez as Lucia Caminos. I’m sure she’s great. You know who hasn’t seen that performance? Literally everybody. We’re nominating acting awards for a performance the public hasn’t watched yet.

The defense is that the jury — 160-plus media outlets — had early access. Fine. But the nominations were announced before the review embargo even lifted. So the biggest night in gaming is built on verdicts the public wasn’t allowed to read, for a game the public wasn’t allowed to play. That’s not an awards show. That’s a marketing event with trophies.

And it’s not just the jury. Fan voting opened the same day the nominations dropped — two days before the game launches. The Game Awards asks fans to vote, and fans are being asked to vote for a game they have not played, in categories like Best Performance and Best Narrative. That’s not a vote. That’s a hype meter. You’re not voting on the best game of the year — you’re voting on the game you’re most excited about. And we already have a category for that. It’s called Most Anticipated. This year, GTA VI skipped that line and went straight for the real trophies.

The Game Awards trophy

And yes, technically, it qualifies. The eligibility cutoff is November 20 at 9 p.m. Pacific, and GTA VI launches November 19. It squeaks in by a day. Legal? Sure. Right? Not even close.

Let’s be honest about why this happened. Rockstar doesn’t need The Game Awards. GTA VI is going to sell a mountain of copies whether it wins a single trophy or not. It’s Geoff Keighley and the show that need Rockstar — the trailers, the headlines, the star power, getting them to participate in future years. So the red carpet gets rolled out, and a game with zero public playtime walks in and takes eight nominations — including a Game of the Year slot in a year the field had to stretch to six because of a tie. Some game that actually came out this year, that real people played and lived with, got squeezed so an unreleased game could get crowned early.

Any other game tries this and it gets laughed out of the room. But it’s GTA, so it gets special treatment. And that’s exactly what this is.

Look at the rest of the Game of the Year field: 007 First Light. Control Resonant. Phantom Blade Zero. Resident Evil Requiem. The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time. Five games that actually came out — games critics reviewed in the open and players actually played. This was their moment, their nomination headlines, and every single story is about GTA. They did everything right and they’re still standing in the shadow of a game that isn’t out. And that’s just the ones who made the list. Every game that shipped this year and fought for a spot lost ground to a game with zero public playtime.

Grand Theft Auto VI artwork showing Jason and Lucia on a dock with the Vice City skyline across the water

And if this is fine now, where does it stop? Next year, does a game launching the week of the show get in? The day before? Do we start nominating games off trailers and press previews as long as the franchise is big enough? The Oscars don’t hand Best Picture nominations to a movie nobody has seen yet. The Grammys don’t give Album of the Year to a record that drops next week. Gaming is the only industry that looked at its biggest prize and said, “Yeah, we can crown this one before it exists.” Once you bend the rule for the biggest game on Earth, the rule is gone. It’s just a suggestion that applies to everybody except Rockstar.

Here’s the part nobody wants to say: if GTA VI is as good as everyone expects, it would have swept next year’s show anyway — with millions of people having actually played it. Let it wait for next year. Let it earn it the same way every other game has to: by coming out first.

And here’s the worst part: this doesn’t even help GTA VI. If it wins Game of the Year on December 10, that trophy comes with an asterisk forever. Half the conversation will be “it won before it was even out.” Rockstar didn’t ask for that. They don’t do the awards circuit — they don’t need to. If this game is the masterpiece everyone expects, it could have won next year, clean, with millions of players behind it and nobody questioning a thing. Instead, the show handed it a head start it never needed — and tainted the win in the process.

I’m a fan. I’ll be playing tomorrow. But a fan can still call it what it is. You don’t get to be Game of the Year before you’re even a game the public can buy. Awards are supposed to be earned. This one got handed over early.

Follow Proven Gamer: X/Twitter | Facebook | Bluesky | Twitch | YouTube | Patreon | TikTok | Instagram | Threads | Discord

Tags: , , , ,

Join the conversation

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.